The Lions’ decision to sign Kyle Allen to compete with Hendon Hooker for the backup quarterback job reflects their commitment to a merit-based depth chart. While the organization has publicly expressed confidence in Hooker, the signing of Allen suggests they are not handing him the No. 2 spot outright.
Hooker’s inexperience stems from both his 2022 ACL injury and the durability of Jared Goff, who has remained consistently available. With Goff securing a major contract extension, Hooker’s path to playing time remains uncertain unless an injury occurs. However, the team still sees potential in him and wants him to prove his value in a competitive setting.
Allen, a journeyman backup with experience across five teams, offers stability and veteran presence. His contract suggests he is not viewed as a long-term option but rather as competition to push Hooker. His starting experience—especially from his 2019 stint in Carolina—demonstrates some capability, though his overall track record (7-12 as a starter) is mixed.
Ultimately, this competition benefits the Lions by ensuring their backup quarterback position is earned rather than given. If Hooker rises to the challenge, it will affirm the organization’s confidence in his development. If not, Allen provides a serviceable fallback option.